Pantelleria is the island you find after you have exhausted the Italian coast. After the Amalfi, which is about the view from the terrace. After Capri, which is about the boat and the grotto and the credit card receipts. After Sicily, which is magnificent and complicated and never quiet. Pantelleria is quiet. It is also volcanic, windswept, and architecturally specific in a way that has nothing to do with the white sugar-cube aesthetic of every other Mediterranean island.
The island lies in the Strait of Sicily, closer to Tunisia than to the Italian mainland. The crossing from Trapani takes two and a half hours by ferry. There are no sandy beaches. The coastline is black lava rock dropping into water that is blue-green in a shade that does not exist in photographs. The interior rises to over eight hundred metres. The wind comes from Africa and does not stop.
The Dammuso
The characteristic building of Pantelleria is the dammuso: a cubic house in grey-black lava stone with a white domed roof and walls thick enough to insulate against the summer heat. The form evolved from Arab occupation between the ninth and eleventh centuries and was adapted to the island's specific conditions: the wind, the volcanic stone, the low rainfall, the weight of heat in July and August. The walls are sometimes a metre thick. The domed roof catches dew and channels it to a cistern below the house. The windows are few and small.
Giardini arabi, the Arabic gardens, are stone enclosures built around citrus trees to protect them from the meltemi. Seen from above, the hillsides are a patchwork of these circular or rectangular walls, each one containing a single lemon or orange tree, the architecture of a patient domestication of impossible conditions. The effect is unlike any other agricultural landscape in the Mediterranean.
Renting a dammuso is the right way to be on Pantelleria. The island has no significant hotel infrastructure of the conventional kind. The best dammusi have been renovated with restraint, the stone floors kept, the thick walls left to do their work, a private pool cut into the rock. The luxury here is thermal: the walls cool what the sun heats, and you understand immediately why the form has not changed in a thousand years.
Zibibbo and the Passito
The Phoenicians brought the Zibibbo grape to Pantelleria in the eighth century B.C. from Egypt. The vine, also known as Moscato d'Alessandria, has grown on this island longer than any current civilization has existed. The vines are trained in the alberello pantesco system: low bushes, pruned close to the ground, planted in hollows sometimes sixty centimetres deep, protected from the wind by their own proximity to the volcanic earth. The system is a UNESCO Intangible Cultural Heritage. It looks, from a distance, like agriculture conducted by people who respect the conditions they are working in.
Passito di Pantelleria is the wine made from Zibibbo grapes dried in the sun until they concentrate into a dense sweetness that carries the mineral character of volcanic soil underneath the fruit. It is a dessert wine in classification and a meditation in practice: amber, viscous, smelling of dried apricot and jasmine and something underneath that is recognizably the black earth of the island. Drink it cold at the end of dinner. Do not hurry it.
Capers from the Right Rock
Pantelleria capers are a Protected Geographical Indication product and the best in the Mediterranean, which is a competitive field. The volcanic soil, the temperature swings between day and night, and the salt-curing method specific to the island produce a caper with a floral, briny complexity that cannot be replicated by the jar from the supermarket shelf.
Insalata Pantesca is the dish that shows the caper at its best: waxy potatoes, red onion, ripe tomatoes, black olives, and a generous quantity of capers, dressed with local olive oil. It arrives at every table, in every restaurant, and is correct every time. The simplicity is not laziness. It is confidence in the quality of the ingredient. Order it first, with cold white wine, before anything else arrives.
The other dishes are the result of the Arab-Sicilian fusion that characterises the island's history: fish couscous, ravioli filled with fresh ricotta and mint, a pastry called mustazzola that is dense with almonds and spiced with cinnamon. The cooking is serious and unfussy in the way that cuisine becomes when the ingredients are genuinely excellent.
The Natural Pools and the Hot Lake
Specchio di Venere, the Mirror of Venus, is a thermal lake in the island's volcanic crater. The water is warm and milky-green, the shore ringed with grey volcanic mud that the regulars apply to their skin and let dry in the sun before washing off in the lake. The effect on the skin is what you would expect from a substance that has been heated from below the earth for ten thousand years. The setting, inside the caldera with the walls rising above the water, is unmistakably geological rather than scenic. It does not look arranged. It looks formed.
The swimming at Gadir, on the eastern coast, is in thermal pools cut into the black lava rock at the sea's edge. The geothermal water meets the cold Mediterranean at the rock rim and the temperature is adjustable by proximity to the source. People have been swimming in these pools since before anyone was writing things down.
The Evening in a Dammuso Courtyard
Dinner on Pantelleria tends to happen late and without urgency. The island has one main town, also called Pantelleria, rebuilt after the Allied bombing of 1943 in a functional style that is the least interesting thing about the island. The restaurants worth going to are outside the town, in the countryside, in terraces cut into the hillside with views over the Strait toward Tunisia.
The evening register is what you pack for the dammuso: simple, good-quality, nothing performing. A silk dress or cotton trousers with a camisole. Flat sandals. The stone under your feet at a hillside restaurant terrace is uneven, and nothing with a heel improves the evening. If the dress is cut with a low back or thin straps, the base layer that holds through three hours of passito and conversation needs to be seamless: silicone covers, ultra-thin at the edge, invisible under any fabric weight. The adhesive releases cleanly. The dress stays as the designer intended. For the Italian wedding guest who finds themselves on the island before the ceremony, the guide to invisible foundations covers the specific requirements.
What Pantelleria Requires
The island does not reward the tourist who needs it to be convenient. The ferry is slow. The roads are narrow and the dammusi are not always easy to find on first arrival. There are no sandy beaches. There is wind.
What Pantelleria gives back: an island with an identity formed over three thousand years, a wine that has not changed since the Phoenicians planted the first vine, a building form that solved the problem of heat and wind before modern architecture existed as a category. The people who know it well do not talk about it often. The island does not need the recommendation.
Heading somewhere this summer? We will send you the packing checklist.
